Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Karena's avatar

The past few years, I've had a very difficult time finding music to listen to or movies to watch. Artists I used to like seem off somehow. Either they have gone woke zombie or Covidian (I won't forgive any artist who required the vax to see them), or the vibe seems hopeless and twisted. It's a combination of ugliness, nihilism, militancy, and inversion that seeps into one's bones simply from contact. Sadly this is also in children's programming.

In the car, if I don't have a playlist downloaded, I listen to a Christian worship radio station. As a former music snob, I used to make fun of Christian rock but now I listen because there is too much darkness in the other music.

Expand full comment
LaFave, Kenneth's avatar

A most insightful piece, thank you. Contemporary pop music has inclined toward the anti-natural (and therefore toward the Satanic) for decades. By that I mean it has inclined toward the denial of harmony. I was a music critic for American newspapers in the '80s, '90s, and early 2000s, and while I tried to stick to classical and jazz (and the standard songs ca. 1920-1960 that jazz covers), once in a while I was forced to deal with current pop. I could hear the decline of harmony from year to year, decade to decade, until what had been the spirit of popular music (of your Jacques Brel, for example, and the many American popular songwriters of the Golden Era) became a zombie. Harmony used to be the place where melody and words married. Now it's just a small set of chords employed to prop up a nominal melody which in turn is there only to convey the darkness of the words. Production is king now, not music. (Curiously, the music of the Miley Cyrus song you cite is something of an exception.)

Expand full comment
189 more comments...

No posts