14 Comments
User's avatar
NewZealandDoc's avatar

There is a very large school of thought that says for great artistry to be achieved screws must be tightened and aspiring artists and performers must run a gauntlet of fire under their teachers and mentors. Some years ago I was a psychiatric consultant to a world-famous music conservatory, and I saw the effects of this approach: uniformly destructive. So, in answer to your question, I give a resounding 'no'.

Expand full comment
Celia Farber's avatar

I do too. It clear from the Balanchine stories (how well he treated his dancers) that Robbins was just sadistic, and it was not necessary.

Expand full comment
blablavatskaya's avatar

who profits from calling an artist a sadist? why play the game of the psychologists, the great sadists of our time?

Expand full comment
Bernard Tamosaitis's avatar

as a 1978 Grad of The Juilliard School I'm interested: can you divulge the name of the world-famous music conservatory?

Expand full comment
Michael Framson's avatar

Thank you Celia for tonight's movie. Everything about dance, the performing arts fascinates me. About an hour into the video, West Side Story is covered. This one line regarding Leonard Bernstein--"Lenny Bernstein was afraid of two things, God and Jerry Robbins".

Expand full comment
Jan Dumas's avatar

That was just what I needed on a very cold, grey, first snow day. I was looking for friends I roomed with in the early 70's from either Joffery or ABT, but of course they were not to be found. In my mind's eye, I saw them dancing though and was totally engulfed in the beauty. Thank you, Celia for this inspired tribute to ballet.

Expand full comment
blablavatskaya's avatar

update: I'm adding my thanks for this video I'd never seen. never had an overarching view of Robbins' career. he's at the heart of so much theater and dance I love. I used to sing BYPSY and WEST SIDE STORY scores around the house. and ON THE TOWN, of course. musical theater ain't what it used to be and choreography? rarely worthy of the name.

naming names at huac is unforgiveable and shows what a sleazy careerist Robbins was, as was Elia Kazan. oh, well. it's our national tragedy we'll never recover from. we're not allowed to contemplate. and not loving Montgomery Clift was another act of cowardice it seems Robbins paid for the rest of his neurotic life.

Expand full comment
Tatiana Bossy's avatar

Celia, please keep us posted more on that fog and about people getting sick. Is your thought another pandemic is on the way?

Expand full comment
Michael Framson's avatar

Celia, to get you off of "studying ill-tempered, talented gay Jewish men in the arts in New York after WW2," how about a little dancing through life--https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h6ReXhrp5Y4

Expand full comment
No One Knows's avatar

they influence American culture and notin a good way..... genetic? or from the source of their own cultural or behavioralinfluences?

Expand full comment
mo's avatar

Out of the shadows of his beginnings the message both silent and spoken by parents both broken was that he wasn't good enough. And he spent a lifetime proving them wrong.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 5
Comment removed
Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 5
Comment removed
Expand full comment
mo's avatar

Just tryin' to steer you away from your gay fixation :- )

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 5
Comment removed
Expand full comment
mo's avatar

Any mentally sound individual should always be open to taking inventory of the forces that have shaped their life. You are no exception.

Expand full comment