The Truth Barrier

Share this post

THE REVOLT IN CHINA: WHAT IT MEANS

celiafarber.substack.com

THE REVOLT IN CHINA: WHAT IT MEANS

Urgent Free Broadcast From JON RAPPOPORT

Celia Farber
Nov 30, 2022
116
50
Share this post

THE REVOLT IN CHINA: WHAT IT MEANS

celiafarber.substack.com

LINK TO RAPPOPORT HERE.

And a few Tweets.

Note: I can’t vouch for everybody whose tweets I share. Together we can weigh and discern. I chose those that stood out to me.

Twitter avatar for @TomMackenzieTV
Tom Mackenzie @TomMackenzieTV
Protests in China are not rare. What *is* rare, are multiple protests over the same issue, at the same time, across the country. The protest below, apparently in central Beijing’s liangmaqiao, is astounding #China #protests
6:28 PM ∙ Nov 27, 2022
30,901Likes9,808Retweets
Twitter avatar for @JackPosobiec
Jack Posobiec 🇺🇸 @JackPosobiec
Families in a hi-rise in China were locked into their apartments as their building caught fire. Urumqi, in Xinjiang Province They burned alive as they couldn't escape and no one could get to them in time This is directly on the CCP and Xi's Zero-Covid lockdown strategy
2:16 AM ∙ Nov 28, 2022
22,098Likes10,751Retweets

Jon Rappoport is a friend and ally of this “war of continuation” (we were both HIV dissent writers in 80s, when Jon published AIDS Inc: Scandal of The Century) since the 1980s. I am an admirer equally of his writings and his broadcasts. Each outstanding. One of the many things I like so much about Jon’s broadcasts is the way he uses time, (as well as cadence,) (and humor.) It distinguishes him from almost all broadcasters working today.


Xi’s Last Slaves: Young Chinese Refusing To Reproduce

Twitter avatar for @johnrackham82
American Soldier for Christ @johnrackham82
My bro is a pilot who flies to China a lot and sent me this: Proficient English speaking Chinese man got on board in a suit and told me: "We're all slaves here. The younger generation knows they are slaves, but they will not reproduce. They said they will be Xi's last slaves."
12:18 PM ∙ Nov 30, 2022
344Likes117Retweets
Twitter avatar for @danwootton
Dan Wootton @danwootton
Now they’re finally awake to the Zero Covid catastrophe in China, the BBC, Sly News, CNN and C4 should apologise for their demonisation of the brave freedom fighters who marched against lockdowns in the UK and the West. They were not conspiracy theorists, they were right.
12:22 PM ∙ Nov 30, 2022
425Likes89Retweets

Free for all to listen: RAPPOPORT LINK HERE.

Twitter avatar for @FoxNews
Fox News @FoxNews
TUCKER CARLSON: “Apple is in no sense American. Apple’s loyalty is to the government of China.”
2:04 AM ∙ Nov 30, 2022
16,592Likes3,841Retweets
Twitter avatar for @WilliamYang120
William Yang @WilliamYang120
Incredible footage from #China’s #Shanghai, where countless people gathered at a road called “#Urumqi road,” chanting a slogan “Step down, the Communist Party” very loudly.
Twitter avatar for @whyyoutouzhele
李老师不是你老师 @whyyoutouzhele
上海乌鲁木齐路 民众高喊 共产党 下台! 这是迄今为止最为激进的口号。 https://t.co/ijP7lxnIgH
7:47 PM ∙ Nov 26, 2022
13,580Likes4,601Retweets
50
Share this post

THE REVOLT IN CHINA: WHAT IT MEANS

celiafarber.substack.com
Previous
Next
50 Comments
Allen
Nov 30, 2022Liked by Celia Farber

Below is a consolidated version of a series of tweets that can be found here:

https://twitter.com/wjhurst/status/1596722048717709312

I've been studying various aspects of protest & contentious politics in China for 25 years.

What's happening now is novel, interesting, & potentially quite important. But we need to be careful about drawing conclusions or making predictions.

Since 1989, we've seen 5 main strands/repertoires of contention in China:

1) labour protest

2) rural protest

3) student protest

4) urban governance protest

5) systematic political dissent

Each of these has usually been disaggregated locally and separated from the others.

Labour politics has seen millions of laid-off (xiagang) SOE workers take to the streets, as well as many hundreds of thousands of their counterparts among migrant workers in export-processing manufacturing industries.

Most demanded workplace protections, union rights, or welfare benefits. But they didn't usually link up cross-regionally or seek common cause with rural residents, students, or others. One significant exception was the so-called Jasic Incident and its aftermath in 2018...

Rural protests have tended to revolve around payment for grain (IOU Crisis), "peasant burdens" (农民负担), provision of essential public goods, or corruption/malfeasance by local officials.

These often have significant impact locally, but seldom beyond.

Student protests have been rarer, but usually either about campus issues or general and philosophical in nature. Occasionally, as in the Jasic Incident, they can be in solidarity with workers, villagers, or others. But they've been largely less significant since June 4.

Many have also noted the prevalence of protests around urban governance and the provision of basic public goods and services - from neighbourhood services to environmental protection, even education and healthcare. These also have tended to be local and specific in nature.

Generalised political dissent is very rare in its expression, but we've seen it from time to time, as in the Charter 08 movement & other manifestations.

Usually repressed quickly and harshly, its impact has mostly been confined to a small set of cosmopolitan intellectuals.

Aside from these, we've also seen ethnic/minority protest (e.g. among Uyghurs or Tibetans), but this has had very limited resonance across the wider population. It's also been extremely harshly repressed, especially since about 2013.

What's happened in the past 24 hours is novel in that protesters have appeared on the streets in multiple cities with apparent knowledge of what is happening in other parts of the country. They're all mobilising around #Covid, but this is refracted through distinct lenses.

This is what makes the current moment especially interesting and possibly important and dangerous. But the trajectory from here is not certain.

I can see at least three possible ways forward, in declining order of likelihood & increasing order of importance/danger...

What is also very interesting, though, is that the state response last night was not nearly as harsh, repressive, or even coordinated as we might have predicted.

If we look at this lacklustre response through the lens of experiences across #Indonesia & SE Asia, it might suggest the lurking presence of at least tacit elite allies. Such a factor would substantially complicate the picture.

But, if we assume no elite backers, the most likely scenario I can see is that the protests fizzle out (as most such movements do in most countries). Having erupted spontaneously in a short period, they will fade away without reaching any climax or denouement.

A second possibility is some form of comprehensive & decisive repression.

This could take the form of a coordinated and possibly quite violent crackdown (as in 1989) or it could be slower-motion and at least somewhat less bloody (as in HK in 2019-2020).

Either form of repression would be extremely costly for the state, however (both in fiscal and reputational terms). It would not be undertaken lightly, as it would also raise the stakes. It's thus a decidedly second-best option and not as likely as the protests fizzling.

A third and much less likely option would be concessions or systemic change. This could range from a relaxation of some #ZeroCovid measures to genuine political opening of some sort. I very much do not think this is in the cards, and would peg probability as extremely low.

If things fizzle - or even if the strands/repertoires become disentangled - all will return to the somewhat uneasy quotidian of a few weeks ago.

If not, this could prove a critical juncture. But not one that will be easy to read in real time or with a happy ending.

(END)

Expand full comment
ReplyGift a subscriptionCollapse
11 replies by Celia Farber and others
INGRID C DURDEN
Nov 30, 2022Liked by Celia Farber

China tried to enslave the world. Now the Chinese will free the world, or at least show the world that locking innocent people up is not the right thing to do. Thanks for sharing, and thanks to Rapoport.

Expand full comment
ReplyGift a subscriptionCollapse
1 reply
48 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Celia Farber
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing